The auditors’
responsibilities are:
responsibilities are:
·
To audit the financial statements. The auditors will
give a ‘true and fair’ report on these
To audit the financial statements. The auditors will
give a ‘true and fair’ report on these
·
If it is a listed company-to review the company’s compliance
with the relevant parts of the combined code. The auditors will report
negatively on this-i.e. they will only report if the company has not complied
with the provisions of the code
If it is a listed company-to review the company’s compliance
with the relevant parts of the combined code. The auditors will report
negatively on this-i.e. they will only report if the company has not complied
with the provisions of the code
·
To read all the rest of the annually report, which
they are not auditing, in order to ensure that it is consistent with the
audited parts and does not give a misleading impression. The auditors, again,
will report negatively, i.e. only if it is not consistent with the financial
accounts.
To read all the rest of the annually report, which
they are not auditing, in order to ensure that it is consistent with the
audited parts and does not give a misleading impression. The auditors, again,
will report negatively, i.e. only if it is not consistent with the financial
accounts.
Auditors’ duties in respect
of compliance with the combined code
of compliance with the combined code
Here we will look specifically at the auditors’ duties
in considering whether or not the company has complied with the provisions of
the combined code.
in considering whether or not the company has complied with the provisions of
the combined code.
The requirement of the code which is relevant to the
auditors can be summarized as:
auditors can be summarized as:
|
Requirement for UK listed
companies |
Auditor requirements
|
|
Principles of good governance
|
|
|
The directors have to disclose in a narrative
|
Read only
|
|
Statement in the annual report how they have
|
|
|
Applied the principles of good corporate governance
|
|
|
Statement of compliance with code provisions
|
|
|
The directors must include in the annual report a
|
Review certain specific
|
|
Statement as to whether or not they have complied
|
Matters, specially the
|
|
Throughout the period with the combined code
|
Internal control report
|
|
Provisions and if not, why not
|
And read the rest
|
|
Directors’ remuneration
|
|
|
Inclusion in the annual report of a statement of
|
Audit and include in the
|
|
Directors’ remuneration including details of the
|
Audit report as if this was in
|
|
Remuneration, pension contributions and
|
The financial statements
|
|
Benefits etc. for each named director
|
|
|
Going concern
|
|
|
The directors must include in the annual report a
|
|
|
Statement that the business is a going concern with
|
|
|
Supporting assumptions or qualifications as
necessary |
|
The auditors duties are covered by ISA 720 (revised)
section A-other information in documents contains audited financial statements;
section-the auditors’ statutory reporting responsibility in relation to
directors’ reports.
section A-other information in documents contains audited financial statements;
section-the auditors’ statutory reporting responsibility in relation to
directors’ reports.
These can be summarized as follows.
The ‘read only’ requirement
for other information
for other information
Any apparent inconsistencies or any apparent
misstatement in the corporate governance statements should be resolved and the
directors should amend the inconsistency.
misstatement in the corporate governance statements should be resolved and the
directors should amend the inconsistency.
If
this does not happen then the auditors should:
this does not happen then the auditors should:
·
If the financial statements are incorrect, qualify
their report.
If the financial statements are incorrect, qualify
their report.
·
If the financial statements are correct and the other
information is incorrect or inadequate, make a statement in the auditors’
report. This statement is however not a qualification.
If the financial statements are correct and the other
information is incorrect or inadequate, make a statement in the auditors’
report. This statement is however not a qualification.
Reviewing the statement of
compliance with the provisions of the code
compliance with the provisions of the code
The review should take the following form:
The auditors should obtain sufficient appropriate
evidence to support the compliance statement made by the company.
evidence to support the compliance statement made by the company.
Appropriate
evidence can be gained by the following procedures:
evidence can be gained by the following procedures:
·
Reviewing the minutes of the meetings of the board and
of relevant board committees (audit, nomination, remuneration, risk management
etc.)
Reviewing the minutes of the meetings of the board and
of relevant board committees (audit, nomination, remuneration, risk management
etc.)
·
Reviewing relevant supporting documents prepared for
the board or board committees.
Reviewing relevant supporting documents prepared for
the board or board committees.
·
Making enquiries of the directors and the company
secretary.
Making enquiries of the directors and the company
secretary.
·
Attending meetings of the audit committee (or other
committee) when the annual report and accounts and statements of compliance are
considered and approved for submission to the board.
Attending meetings of the audit committee (or other
committee) when the annual report and accounts and statements of compliance are
considered and approved for submission to the board.
·
The auditors may ask for a letter of representation of
any written or oral representations made in the course of the review
The auditors may ask for a letter of representation of
any written or oral representations made in the course of the review
If the auditors are not
satisfied with the directors’ compliance statement they will include an
explanatory comment in their auditors’ report .
satisfied with the directors’ compliance statement they will include an
explanatory comment in their auditors’ report .