Thomas J. Yeggy Argues Annie Jacobsen’s Worst-Case Nuclear Scenario Is Technologically and Strategically Impossible
Pensacola Beach, FL — Thomas J. Yeggy, JD, a former mental health judge and legal scholar with decades of experience in decision-making under crisis conditions, has released a detailed review of Annie Jacobsen’s bestselling book Nuclear War: A Scenario, raising serious concerns about the book’s technical accuracy and its portrayal of nuclear decision-making.
Jacobsen presents her book as a nonfiction, realistic depiction of how cascading events could lead to an all-out nuclear war. While acknowledging Jacobsen’s reputation and the gripping pace of her narrative, Yeggy argues that the scenario she presents is not only misleading but, in several key respects, impossible.
Drawing on publicly available defense analyses, military technology assessments, and critiques from Air University Press, Yeggy contends that Nuclear War: A Scenario relies on worst-case assumptions that leave no room for de-escalation, institutional safeguards, or real-world deterrence mechanisms. He notes that the book simplifies the complexity of nuclear command-and-control systems and overlooks the layered decision-making, allied coordination, and verification processes designed specifically to prevent accidental or rushed escalation.
Central to Yeggy’s critique is Jacobsen’s depiction of a sudden, limited North Korean nuclear strike triggering an unavoidable global nuclear exchange. According to Yeggy, this premise collapses under scrutiny. He challenges the feasibility of the weapons systems described, including the capabilities attributed to North Korea’s Hwasong-17 missile, the yields of its warheads, and the likelihood that U.S. missile defense systems would entirely fail. He further argues that the book’s submarine-based second strike scenario ignores modern undersea surveillance capabilities maintained by Japan and the United States, making such an undetected launch extraordinarily unlikely.
Yeggy also disputes the book’s portrayal of nuclear launch timelines, particularly the insistence that U.S. leadership would have only minutes to respond. He argues that this sense of immediacy exaggerates the realities of launch-on-warning policies and underestimates the survivability of U.S. retaliatory forces, especially submarine-based deterrents.
While critical of the book’s technical claims, Yeggy emphasizes that his review is not a dismissal of the dangers of nuclear war. On the contrary, he praises Jacobsen’s vivid depiction of the catastrophic humanitarian consequences of nuclear weapons use. His concern, he says, is that presenting an implausible scenario as inevitable risks misleading the public and fostering fatalism rather than informed understanding.
“Nuclear War: A Scenario is compelling and frightening,” Yeggy writes, “but it needs a heavy disclaimer. The scenario depicted is not only technologically flawed, but it also misrepresents how nuclear deterrence, detection, and decision-making actually function.”
Yeggy’s full review calls for more rigorous public discussion grounded in current technology and strategy, warning that fear-driven narratives unsupported by facts may do more harm than good.
More information is available at:
http://www.thomasjyeggy.com/blog/nuclear-war-a-scenario-by-annie-jacobsen-a-review
Thomas J. Yeggy is a graduate of the University of Iowa College of Law who practiced law in Iowa and Illinois and served for more than 25 years as a mental health judge, authoring over 1,500 judicial opinions. A licensed Series 7 broker, Yeggy has long studied nuclear weapons control and deterrence, influenced by firsthand exposure to the legacy of Hiroshima and Nagasaki and historical reflections on the Cuban Missile Crisis. He is the author of the First Strike series and the recipient of the 2024 Reader’s House Magazine Editor’s Choice Award of Literary Excellence. He currently resides in Pensacola Beach, Florida.
Contact:
Thomas J. Yeggy
Website: Thomasjyeggy.com
Email: Upn42@yahoo.com
